The Federal Fiscal Court has ruled on when a service provider acts as an intermediary or as an independent service provider in the context of vehicle rentals. The central issue was whether the plaintiff’s activities (via its internet platform) should be classified as brokerage services or as independent vehicle rental services. The Finance Court had previously determined that the plaintiff, as Landlady occurred. The Federal Fiscal Court corrected this analysis and classified the plaintiff’s activity as Brokerage Activities one.
Practical example:
The plaintiff operated her business from a third country via her website. Customers could book rental cars from various providers through the website. The plaintiff’s website was displayed to the customer in his or her native language after the customer entered his or her place of residence. If the customer wished to rent a car, he or she entered all required information via an input form. The customer then received an overview of the available vehicle categories from the individual car rental companies and the respective prices. After entering their contact and payment information and accepting the plaintiff’s Terms and Conditions, the customer could complete a binding reservation.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) emphasized that an intermediary does not provide a "service of its own" if the vehicles it arranges are not rented by the intermediary itself. In this case, the plaintiff expressly acted as an intermediary vis-à-vis the customers and organized the reservations and administrative processing on behalf of the actual vehicle rental companies. The contractual provisions stipulating that the plaintiff acted solely as an intermediary were decisive. The BFH found that the economic reality of the transactions was consistent with these agreements, since the plaintiff’s customers ultimately entered into a rental agreement directly with the actual rental company. The fact that the plaintiff received payments from customers in advance was not decisive for classifying it as a rental company.
Conclusion: The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) therefore concluded that the plaintiff acted exclusively as an intermediary and that the Car Rental Company who is the recipient of the payment and, therefore, the party liable for tax. The tax court's ruling was overturned.